Skip to content

Evidence library

Eating canned soup for five days raised the BPA in people’s urine more than tenfold

Food and drink cans have a thin plastic lining. In a 2011 Harvard trial, people who ate one can of soup a day had more than ten times as much bisphenol A (BPA) in their urine as when they ate fresh soup.

Authors / organisation
Carwile J.L., Ye X., Zhou X., Calafat A.M. and Michels K.B.
Year
2011
Journal or publisher
JAMA
Digital object identifier (DOI)
10.1001/jama.2011.1721
Study type
Randomised trial
Evidence strength
Evidence: Medium
Sample / scope
75 adult volunteers in Boston, US; five days of canned soup and five days of fresh soup, in random order
Key finding
After five days of eating a can of soup a day, the BPA in volunteers' urine was more than ten times higher than after five days of fresh soup.
Headline number
More than 10 times the BPA after a week of canned soup
Caveats / how it is misquoted
Small, short trial measuring BPA in urine, not health effects. Most cans sold today, especially in the US and the European Union, no longer use BPA linings; the replacement plastics are less studied.
Open access
Yes
Verified on
3 October 2026

Food and drink cans have a thin plastic lining on the inside, so the metal does not react with the food. For decades that lining was usually an epoxy plastic made with bisphenol A (BPA), a chemical that can mimic hormones in the body.

Researchers at the Harvard School of Public Health asked 75 volunteers to eat a serving of canned vegetarian soup every day for five days, and fresh soup every day for another five days. After the canned soup week, the BPA in their urine was more than ten times higher than after the fresh soup week.

Cans have changed since 2011. In the US, the can makers' trade body said about 90% of food cans were made without BPA by 2018. The European Union banned BPA in food packaging from 20 January 2025, with extra time for some cans. Australia has no ban; Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) says BPA levels in Australian food are low and unlikely to harm health. The newer linings, mostly acrylic and polyester, are still plastic, and far less is known about what they release.

Why it matters: even food that looks plastic-free can come in plastic. Fresh, frozen or dried food avoids the question, and dried beans and lentils usually cost less than canned ones.

Sources last verified 3 October 2026. Page updated 3 October 2026. How we check sources